women in the holocaust
The state of research into the experience of women in concentration camps
during the Holocaust is fraught with controversy. Since the most prolific and
famous voices of Holocaust survivors have tended to be men, such as Victor
Frankl and Elie Weisel, scholars have wondered if the voice of the female
survivor has been ignored. However, some, including famous feminists like Hanna
Arendt, have questioned this claim as possibly detracting from the overall
atrocities committed by the Nazis, and negating the fact that it was not men or
women who were targeted for death, but Jews. Despite this controversy, it can be
argued that significant differences did exist between the experiences of male
and female victims in the Nazi concentration camps.
Victor Frankl, and many other male survivors reported that after the
demoralization of the camps, men became individualistic, concerned only for
their own personal survival. Many female survivors, such as Lucille E. claim
that the experience of women was quite different. Women in the camps tended to
work together, trying to maintain some semblance of the nurturing role they had
held in their previous lives. Women in the notorious female concentration camp
Ravensbruck cared for one another and had a social network that included holding
classes in language, geography, and music. Some theater was staged, and drawing
scenes of camp life was a common activity as well. In the first few years of the
camp, the women even published a secret newsletter.
Womens experience in concentration camps was also different from that of the men
because of simple physical differences. Many women who arrived at the camp were
pregnant, and pregnant Jews were immediately gassed. Poles, Slavs, Russian, and
German pregnancies were ended by forced abortion if possible. Women who gave
birth in the camps usually watched their newborns die immediately, and those
that survived were killed by the camp doctors or nurses.
Amenorrhea, or loss of menses, was a common part of life in the camps because of
the lack of food and hard labor. This, along with the loss of hair (a potent
symbol of sexuality to Jewish women at the time) combined to make most survivors
report a wrenching loss of femininity and individuality. Survivors reported that
the shaven heads especially led to an assimilation of the female identity into a
single mass of naked, ugly bodies. Despite their own perceived lack of
sexuality, women were also victimized sexually in a way different from men.
Though male survivors also report rape and molestation being common, for women,
sexuality was a much more defining characteristic. Physical beauty could have a
direct effect on survival for women in the German concentration camps, despite
the fact that most were emaciated and clothed in rags. Himmler, Adolf Hitlers
head of the Nazi SS, even set up a brothel system, taking around twenty women
from Ravensbruck for each of the camps that housed men. These women were used as
sexual rewards for the most valuable and cooperative non-Jewish male prisoners.
Interestingly, the survival rate of women who were not immediately executed was
higher than that of men, though the reasons for this are debated. Some theories
point to the higher percentage of body fat to muscle as a main contributing
factor to their ability to survive starvation. Ravensbruck itself was eventually
liberated while the camp was still mostly a labor intensive facility and not an
annihilation camp. But many of the women survivors themselves point to a
different reason: sheer tenacity and the ability to nurture each other in the
face of demoralizing humiliation. Though scholars and feminists debate whether
or not this was actually true, it is clear that women formed bonds within the
concentration camps that they believed helped them to deal with the emotional
and physical torture they suffered.